TNO starts multi-annual study on the effects of wind turbine shade on solar parks

09 Feb 2021

Together with project partners Heliox and Zwanendal and solar energy producers Vattenfall and Solarfields, TNO has entered into a consortium to investigate the effects of shade on the energy yield of solar parks. Solar energy and wind energy are to some extent complementary and therefore an excellent combination for energy generation. Solar parks and wind parks are being combined at an increasing number of locations. A disadvantage of this combination is that the solar panels may be subjected to the shade of the wind turbines. Little is known as yet about how this affects the solar park performance.

Based on the findings, the consortium will draft recommendations on the application of power electronics and on the design and operation of combined solar and wind farms. The aim is to maximise the energy yield and limit the stresses on and failures of electrical components. The research project will run until the end of October 2022.

Investigating shade effects

Haringvliet energy park is Vattenfall's first hybrid park. It consists of six wind turbines, 115,000 solar panels and 12 containers with batteries. Photo: Vattenfall / Jorrit Lousberg

Wind turbines and solar panels are an excellent combination because they can jointly use the same electricity connection without large yield losses, says TNO researcher Nico Dekker: "Ideally, the wind turbines should be on the north side of the plot and the solar panels on the south side. However, this is not always possible, resulting in shade from the wind turbines on the solar panels. We distinguish on the one hand the slowly moving shadow caused by the turbine tower and on the other hand the dynamic, rapidly moving shadow caused by the turbine blades. The slowly moving shadow can be easily incorporated into the design. However, relatively little is known about the dynamic, rapidly moving shadow, which is why we are going to investigate it. An earlier TNO study, in which dynamic shading was investigated on a small scale, showed that a dynamic shadow can lead to greater energy loss than an equally large slowly moving shadow. Application of the right power electronics can reduce this effect and thus also limit the additional load on the installation.

To measure is to know

To determine the effect of shade, TNO will conduct detailed, high-frequency measurements at operational solar parks operated by Solarfields and Vattenfall. TNO's simulation models will be used to determine the effect of slowly moving and rapidly moving shading on the performance of and stresses on solar panels and power electronics such as inverters. Heliox will analyse the stresses on the power electronics and how this relates to the system design and the control algorithms. Based on this, the project partners will draw up recommendations for the design and selection of power electronics and for the design and operation of combined solar and wind farms. The aim is to maximise the energy yield and reduce the load and failures of electrical components.

Looking for measuring locations

TNO will carry out operational measurements in the solar parks of a number of solar energy producers, but would like to involve some additional solar parks in the study. If you are interested, please contact project leader Josco Kester.


Innovation and the rise of solar energy

The sun is an infinite source of energy for all life on earth. For several decades, we humans have been able to convert the light of this star into electricity and heat. In time, we can be independent... Read more
Our work

Solar farms respecting landscape and nature

In ten years’ time, our country is expected to generate five times as much solar energy compared to 2020. Some scenarios assume that the amount will be almost 20 times as much by 2050, requiring a substantial... Read more

Towards large-scale generation of wind energy

The Dutch government has agreed with the energy sector that the near future will already see that energy generated from sustainable sources will be a substantial share of the energy mix. The future Dutch energy... Read more

Josco Kester

  • PV Modules & Applications

Media questions?