Towards new methods for designing wind turbines

Offshore wind farms
Optimised design and operation of large OWF’s
16 February 2023

The height of wind turbines and the length of their blades are increasing apace. As a result, the huge forces exerted on the blades and rotor hub are becoming even greater. Calculating how wind behaves at a wind farm and what that means for the levelized costs of energy has many uncertainties. TNO, together with Delft-based company Whiffle, has developed a new research method that significantly reduces the gap between simulation and reality.

Innovative calculation methods

The findings have been published in the report ‘Towards the use of Large Eddy Simulations (LES) for the generation of the Atmospheric Boundary Layer (ABL) inflow for wind turbine load calculations (pdf)’, which was co-sponsored by the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy through Energy Innovation NL. The research is part of a project that aims to make offshore wind cheaper by developing innovative calculation methods for modelling wind behaviour. The consortium, led by TNO, also includes Whiffle and GE Wind Energy GmbH.

New methods for designing wind turbines

TNO Whiffle joint report: Towards the use of large eddy simulations for the  generation of the atmospheric boundary layer inflow for wind turbine load calculations

Atmospheric wind complexity

‘The aim was to enable more realistic modelling of the performance and reliability of wind turbines operating in the field. These factors are the result of the aerodynamic interaction between the wind and the turbine blades. Loads depend to a large extent on the characteristics of the wind field. The atmospheric wind behaviour is complex and site-specific. Wind behaves erratically and unpredictably.

Current models are still too simple and based on statistics and assumptions that are not representative of the high variation in the conditions at a wind farm. There is still a gap between what wind turbine designers use for their calculations and what happens once the turbines have been installed and put into operation at sea or on land’, says TNO expert Simone Mancini.

New insights

TNO and Whiffle have been collaborating for some time now on the AeroLES project, ‘Load calculation innovations using Large-Eddy-Simulations’. This project is developing and validating new computational methods to take into account the complexity of real atmospheric wind when designing new-generation wind turbines.

The latest research combined Whiffle’s atmospheric models with TNO’s wind turbine aerodynamics models. Wind field predictions obtained with the new numerical tool were validated against real wind measurements at a ridge in Germany, a plain in the Netherlands and at the North Sea. The results offer designers of wind turbines new insights into ways to make them cheaper and more efficient.

Realistic atmospheric conditions

Simone: ‘The aim was to take the LES simulations to the next level allowing designers to benefit from more realistic inflow modelling to get more reliable estimates of their wind turbine’s expected loads and performance once it is placed on the field. The fact that we’ve been able to design a new methodology is down to the enormous computing power now offered by graphics processors. This allowed us to capture realistic atmospheric conditions with our LES model at reasonable computational costs. There’s still more to be done, though. The next phase will involve validating the new load predictions against real load measurements from an instrumented turbine that TNO is currently testing on the field. But the foundations have now been laid for this.’

Learn more about the next generation wind turbines

Wind turbine with 145-metre blades: reduced costs and greater efficiency

Get inspired

15 resultaten, getoond 6 t/m 10

Offshore wind under pressure

31 December 2022
1 aflevering

Offshore wind energy is growing enormously, but this growth comes with challenges. To maximize the value of large volumes of wind energy in the future energy system, we need to ensure feasible business cases for developers.

Profitability offshore wind in 2030 not self-evident

17 November 2022

A new TNO study reveals that offshore wind will not be profitable in all cases. Using several scenarios, TNO investigated the feasibility of offshore wind energy in 2030.

TNO innovation offers discarded wind turbine blades a circular future

17 October 2022

Wind energy is gaining momentum. TNO is advanced with a promising solution for recycling discarded wind turbine blades.

Image: Brightlands Materials Center

GROW enters next phase offshore wind

14 October 2022

Twenty leading offshore wind parties extend their successful cooperation on innovation to 2030. GROW, a consortium of leading offshore wind industry and research partners, started as a six-years innovation programme.

Designing sustainable wind turbines for the circular economy


At the end of their life wind turbine blades end up as landfill. TNO is working on the design of turbine blades that can be recycled.