Climate change makes carbon sinks more vulnerable
Natural carbon sinks such as the ocean and forests are not stable. Climate change makes these sinks more vulnerable, in some cases even turning them into carbon emitters. This compromises current climate targets and action plans. These are recent scientific findings from the new ICOS publication, compiled by a large team of ICOS researchers, to which TNO is a contributor.
Curious about the research?
Read the new publication by ICOS
Natural and human factors can cause natural carbon sinks
A large team of researchers from ICOS shows that natural and human factors can cause natural carbon sinks such as forests, crop fields, or parts of the ocean to become carbon emitters.
Using data from long-term ground-based observations, the researchers conclude in FLUXES that the natural shifts in carbon concentrations are related, for example, to changes in weather over the years: wet and dry seasons, warm and cold temperatures, as well as more extreme events such as droughts, forest fires, or floods.
All these are expected to occur more frequently in the future due to global warming.
Anthropogenic emissions are more variable than in the past
Our TNO experts emphasise in their share of the study that anthropogenic emissions are also more variable than in the past. The COVID-19 pandemic (temporarily less emissions), war in Ukraine (more emissions because less gas, more coal) are examples.
"Ultimately, we need to monitor the balance of all these factors and adjust our policies accordingly." says Hugo Denier van der Gon.
Natural carbon sinks are becoming increasingly vulnerable
Further, it is shown in FLUXES how human actions have a direct impact: thinning or clear-cutting forests, or changing agricultural practices change the ecosystem’s ability to sink carbon for years.
“We usually rely on natural sinks as our stable allies when it comes to absorbing the fossil fuel emissions,” says Dr Werner Kutsch, Director-General of ICOS. “Unfortunately, they are not! Natural carbon sinks vary from year to year, and they are becoming increasingly fragile,” he points out.
The decreasing carbon sinks have a direct and important impact on national and European carbon neutrality strategies relying on natural sinks behaving as constant carbon absorbers.
"Because current carbon-neutral strategies do not integrate the variability of carbon sinks, and tend to underestimate the related risks, the current projections simply don't match the reality," warns Dr Kutsch. "This directly threatens the course to maintain the 1.5°C goal," he states.
“With natural sinks at risk and technological solutions to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere still costly and highly uncertain, the FLUXES researchers agree that there is only one foreseeable solution: to drastically reduce fossil fuel emissions to keep the 1.5°C target of the Paris Agreement. As difficult as it may be: we have to come out of the current energy crisis with drastic reductions in our fossil fuel emissions,” concludes Dr Kutsch.
FLUXES publication highlights climate issues
FLUXES, the European Greenhouse Gas Bulletin is a new publication by ICOS, the Integrated Carbon Observation System, which aims at highlighting climate issues to an audience of policymakers, policy advisors, and climate journalists. The first volume of FLUXES focuses on regional and year-over-year changes in carbon sinks in Europe. These changing sinks highlight the need to reduce emissions further in order to reach carbon neutrality targets.
Hugo Denier van der GonFunctie:Principal Scientist
I seek to identify, investigate and understand the consequences of human activities on the environment, especially on air quality and global climate change. I believe sound science can make a difference in the complex, but necessary, transition to a sustainable society.
Martijn SchaapFunctie:Professor Atmospheric Chemistry
Major environmental challenges of the 21st century relate to the composition of our atmosphere. Exposure to pollutants such as particulate matter is associated with significant health impacts. Deposition of atmospheric reactive nitrogen causes a loss of biodiversity in ecosystems through eutrophication.
Looking for another expert?View all experts
How CCU can shape the carbon transition
Carbon capture and utilisation, or CCU, is a technology that involves capturing CO2 emitted from (industrial) processes and using it to make new products. It therefore doesn’t only reduce CO2 emissions, it creates new market potential. Government and industry alike see the necessity of understanding which CCU value chains are future-proof and economically, environmentally and politically viable. The Province of Zuid-Holland wanted to know what role CCU has in the future for the province.